Turn this list into pipeline.
Insurance Companies in Sheffield: 117 Active Firms (2026)
Insurance companies in Sheffield underwrite, broker and administer risk-transfer products for households and businesses across South Yorkshire.
Buying centres tend to sit with owner-managed businesses, household customers and specialist commercial clients rather than national enterprise procurement teams. Commercial lines, personal lines and claims services each create a different sales motion: advice-led placements for local SMEs, renewal-led servicing for households, and back-office policy work for niche sectors. The likely buyer is local, cost-conscious and relationship-led, with engagements sized around recurring premiums, commission income or service fees rather than large platform contracts. Teams are typically small to lower-mid-market, so researcher attention should fall on authorisation status, revenue evidence and whether activity is advisory, underwriting-agency or administrative.
Read more
Sheffield has 117 actively trading insurance firms in this list, a compact local cohort rather than a national platform cluster. Reported headcount totals 315, which points to branch-style brokerages, claims-services teams and small policy administrators rather than labour-intensive carriers. No firms sit above £5M in turnover, so the local picture appears concentrated in smaller operators with measurable revenue but limited scale. Recent formation is present, with 14 firms incorporated since 2022, although the active base still reads more like a relationship-led services market than a high-volume formation market.
Permissioned activity matters because this cohort mixes brokers, underwriting agencies, claims administrators and policy-services providers. A brokerage model usually brings conduct, disclosure, suitability, complaints and client-money obligations; delegated underwriting adds governance around pricing authority, binder oversight and insurer capacity; claims administration brings service-level scrutiny and complaints risk. Sheffield’s small-team profile also makes appointed-representative and outsourced operations worth checking, because a local trading address may sit within a wider permission structure. Researchers should separate revenue from advisory commission, delegated-authority fees and administrative service income before comparing firms.
Local insurance activity appears steady rather than expansive. Demand tends to follow household churn, SME formation and specialist commercial renewal cycles, so organic growth is likely to depend more on retained relationships than on new product launches. Smaller brokers and administrators may face continued margin pressure from compliance workload, insurer appetite and digital servicing expectations, which can make consolidation attractive where owners lack succession options. Scale-up scarcity also matters: without many larger turnover anchors, Sheffield’s cohort appears more likely to produce incremental branch growth, acquisitions and niche specialisation than a wave of nationally visible carriers.
117
Active firms
2026
14
Recent incorporations
Since 2022
0
Over £5M
Annual revenue
Key facts
11% of the cohort was incorporated since 2022 (14 firms), so a sizeable share is in its first few filing cycles.
Sheffield insurance activity covers underwriting, broking and administration, with products aimed at households and businesses across South Yorkshire.
Risk-transfer services sit close to local trade and household finance, because they shape how buyers manage exposure rather than only how they purchase financial products.
The local mix appears to include brokerage-led, administration-heavy and underwriting-related models, so revenue per employee is a useful screening lens.
Household and business cover create different sales motions, from standardised policy placement to adviser-led commercial broking.
Top Sheffield Insurance companies
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsProvides legal expenses insurance and related cover for households, landlords and businesses, including home emergency, motor excess, rent guarantee and replacement vehicle policies, alongside claims…
Serves insurance brokers and policyholders across personal, landlord and commercial markets, including households, tenants, homebuyers, landlords, motorhome owners, fleet operators, motor traders and…
Financial Health
StrongStrong · Hiring · 18% CAGR over 4y
Location
Actus Risk Management Services Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsProvides insurance broking and risk management services, arranging general insurance policies for businesses and offering advice on identifying, assessing, and mitigating operational and financial…
Serves businesses seeking insurance and risk management support, with a clear focus on manufacturers and other commercial organisations needing general insurance and related advice.
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · Hiring · 14% CAGR over 4y
Location
Think Driver Insure Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed
Location
Motorway Direct Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StableStable · -41% CAGR over 4y
Location
AA Mechanical Insurance Services Limited
Trajectory
3y · 2019–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed
Location
Insured Health Ltd
Trajectory
3y · 2023–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsActs as a health insurance broker comparing private medical insurance policies from insurers such as Bupa, AXA and Aviva. Provides advice, quotes and policy recommendations for individuals, families,…
Serves UK consumers seeking private health cover, including individuals, families and seniors, as well as businesses reviewing or buying employee health insurance policies.
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · -2% CAGR over 2y
Location
Provides health cash plan schemes for individuals and employers, reimbursing routine healthcare costs such as dental, optical and prescriptions, and offering employee wellbeing services including…
Sells to employers of varying sizes seeking staff health benefits and absence support, as well as individual consumers, including over-50s, who want everyday healthcare expense cover.
Location
Cobdell Limited
Financial Health
Insufficient historyInsufficient history
Location
London Wall Insurance Services Limited
Financial Health
Insufficient historyInsufficient history
Location
Mortgage Advice Hub Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
WeakWeak · -5% CAGR over 4y
Location
IFM INSURANCE BROKERS LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StableStable · -3% CAGR over 4y
Location
DELAMAIN OGILBY LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsActs as an independent insurance broker and consultant, arranging insurance coverage and providing advisory services. Sources and places policies through Lloyd’s and the wider insurance market, and…
Financial Health
StableStable · -7% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsProvides accident management services for taxi drivers, including handling non‑fault insurance claims, supplying licensed replacement taxi vehicles, vehicle recovery and storage, and coordinating…
Serves taxi drivers and taxi operators in the UK, including private hire and hackney carriage drivers involved in non-fault road accidents, plus referrers of taxi claims.
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · Hiring · 2% CAGR over 4y
Location
THE PI DESK LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StableStable · -65% CAGR over 4y
Location
Protect What Matters Most Limited
Trajectory
4y · 2023–NowFinancial Health
Insufficient historyInsufficient history
Location
Insure Protect Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StableStable · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
HARMER HEALEY LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed · -71% CAGR over 4y
Location
The Motoring Organisation Limited
Trajectory
3y · 2023–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsProvides vehicle aftercare products for motorists, including breakdown assistance and roadside recovery services arranged through third‑party providers such as The AA. Offers customer support and…
Serves UK motorists and vehicle owners seeking aftercare products and support, including customers buying or managing breakdown-related cover.
Financial Health
StableStable · Hiring · 5% CAGR over 2y
Location
WILBYS LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsProvides insurance brokerage services, advising businesses and individuals and arranging commercial and personal insurance policies. Offers specialist cover for sectors such as transport, motor…
Serves businesses and private clients across Yorkshire and beyond, including charities, leisure operators, motor trade firms, holiday parks, social care providers, transport businesses, and…
Financial Health
StableStable · -3% CAGR over 4y
Location
A S Insurance Services Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsIndependent insurance broker arranging business and personal insurance policies. Provides advice, quotes, policy placement and claims support, including specialist cover for hospitality businesses…
Serves individuals and businesses seeking insurance, with emphasis on Yorkshire clients and hospitality-sector firms such as micropubs and microbreweries.
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · -1% CAGR over 5y
Location
Provides insurance administration and outsourced services including third‑party administration, underwriting support, claims management, and policy lifecycle management. Develops and manages…
Serves B2B insurance partners, including insurers, underwriters, brokers, household brands and high street retailers seeking white-label or outsourced insurance administration, claims and specialist…
Location
Dobson & Hodge Limited
Trajectory
4y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 4 filingsProvides insurance brokerage and independent financial advice to individuals and businesses, arranging commercial and personal insurance policies and advising on pensions, investments, retirement…
Serves individuals, people acting for others, and businesses of all sizes across industries, trades and professions, including commercial clients and employers.
Financial Health
StableStable · 2% CAGR over 3y
Location
Provides insurance administration and outsourced services including underwriting, claims management and third‑party administration. Designs and manages white‑label and affinity insurance products,…
Serves insurers, underwriters, brokers and consumer brands or high-street retailers involved in specialist insurance, including affinity partners with non-core, complex or white-label insurance…
Location
Trusted Mortgage & Protection Advisors Ltd
Trajectory
2y · 2024–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 2 filingsProvides mortgage brokerage and protection insurance advice for homebuyers, remortgaging clients and buy‑to‑let investors. Assists with mortgage applications, compares lenders and advises on life…
Serves consumers in Rotherham seeking mortgage and protection advice, including first-time buyers, home movers, remortgagers and families, plus buy-to-let property investors and business owners…
Financial Health
WeakWeak · 0% CAGR over 1y
Location
Intelligent PMI Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsAdvises and arranges private medical insurance policies for individuals, families and businesses. Researches the health insurance market, provides quotes, assists clients in switching providers, and…
Sells to individuals, families and businesses seeking private medical insurance, including employers buying healthcare cover as an employee benefit for staff. Serves UK customers comparing, switching…
Financial Health
DistressedDistressed · -6% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsArranges business insurance policies including commercial, motor fleet, liability, property, cyber and professional indemnity cover. Acts as an insurance broker placing risks with insurers and the…
Serves UK businesses seeking commercial insurance, including construction, haulage, manufacturing, logistics and engineering firms, plus dealerships, garages, fleet operators, landlords and…
Financial Health
StrongStrong · -3% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trendlord Financial Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsActs as an insurance broker arranging commercial insurance policies for businesses. Assesses client risks, advises on cover, and sources policies from multiple insurers, including specialist products…
Serves UK businesses needing commercial insurance advice and cover, including organisations with medical malpractice risks, across varied sectors and company sizes.
Financial Health
StableStable · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
Hoyland Insurance Brokers Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsArranges and brokers general insurance policies for businesses and individuals, including commercial property cover and personal policies such as home, motor, travel and other general insurance…
Serves both businesses and private individuals, from companies requiring commercial or property cover to consumers seeking home, car, travel and other personal insurance policies.
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · -8% CAGR over 4y
Location
KAYS INSURANCE BROKERS LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsProvides commercial insurance brokerage services for businesses, advising on coverage and arranging policies such as property, liability and other business risk insurance through regulated insurers.
Serves business customers seeking commercial insurance, indicating a B2B focus on companies needing cover for their operations rather than consumers.
Financial Health
StableStable · Hiring · 9% CAGR over 4y
Location
Aspire Lending Solutions Limited
Trajectory
4y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 4 filingsFinancial Health
StrongStrong · Growing · 0% CAGR over 3y
Location
Barnes Independent Services Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
HealthyHealthy · Growing · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
EVOLVE FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
HealthyHealthy · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
HealthyHealthy · -16% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trajectory
5y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsArranges surety bonds and financial guarantees for businesses and contractors. Services include performance, bid and tender bonds, retention and advance payment bonds, and guarantees for HMRC,…
Serves businesses of all sizes needing surety bonds and guarantees, including contractors, construction firms, outsourcing providers, environmental operators and companies with HMRC, pension, VAT or…
Financial Health
HealthyHealthy · Hiring · 7% CAGR over 4y
Location
Trajectory
3y · 2023–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsArranges private medical insurance, health cash plans, dental plans and wellbeing products for people working in the education sector. Offers individual and group healthcare policies for teachers,…
Sells to people working in the education sector, including teachers, lecturers, trainers and staff at nurseries, schools, academies, colleges and universities, plus their families. Also serves…
Financial Health
StableStable · Hiring · 15% CAGR over 2y
Location
PRESTIGE COMMERCIAL FINANCE LIMITED
Trajectory
3y · 2022–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsProvides financial advice and brokerage services including mortgage advice (first-time buyer, remortgage, buy-to-let), personal insurance and protection policies, general insurance, secured loans,…
Serves a mix of consumers and businesses, including first-time buyers, homemovers, remortgagers, buy-to-let landlords, individuals seeking protection cover, and corporate clients needing finance or…
Financial Health
StableStable · -90% CAGR over 2y
Location
GP Motor Solutions Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
HealthyHealthy · Hiring · 19% CAGR over 4y
Location
FACE TO FACE FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS (LEEDS) LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
WeakWeak · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
Touchwood Insurance Brokers Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StableStable · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
Ideal Brokers Limited
Trajectory
3y · 2023–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 3 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed · 0% CAGR over 2y
Location
RELIANT INSURANCE AGENCY LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed · -10% CAGR over 4y
Location
Poultney Financial Services Limited
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
WeakWeak · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
RYAN LYSONS INS SERVICES LTD
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
WeakWeak · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
KLI GROUP LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
DistressedDistressed
Location
SHAUN LAX FINANCIAL CONSULTING LIMITED
Trajectory
5y · 2021–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
WeakWeak · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
CFS Mortgage Brokers Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StrongStrong · Growing · 0% CAGR over 4y
Location
H&L MORTGAGE SOLUTIONS LTD
Trajectory
1y · 2025–NowFinancial Health
Insufficient historyInsufficient history
Location
Dsimps Ltd
Trajectory
1y · 2025–NowFinancial Health
Insufficient historyInsufficient history
Location
ALBION FINANCIAL ADVICE SERVICES LTD
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
HealthyHealthy · -4% CAGR over 5y
Location
St Private Healthcare Ltd
Trajectory
5y · 2020–NowFinancial sub-scores
Computed from 5 filingsFinancial Health
StrongStrong · Hiring · 32% CAGR over 4y
Location
Unlock all 117 leads
Showing 50 of 117 — +67 more with verified decision-maker contacts, live data, and CRM sync.
How Sheffield Insurance companies work and how to sell to them
What they do
Revenue usually comes from commission on placed premiums, broker fees, delegated-authority fees and service charges for claims or policy administration. Sheffield insurance firms are more likely to sell advice, placement and servicing capacity than owned risk capital, so the commercial asset is customer access, insurer relationships and process control. Pricing tends to follow annual renewal cycles: a household or small-business policy may generate recurring commission, while specialist commercial work can involve a fee for advice, documentation or mid-term changes. Underwriting-agency and administrative models may be paid by capacity providers through binder fees, handling fees or per-policy charges.
Who they sell to
Most buyers are local households, owner-managed businesses and specialist commercial clients that value availability and trust over formal procurement. In SME placements, the decision maker is often the owner, finance lead, office manager or operations head; for specialist commercial risks, a director or external adviser may shape the brief. Sales cycles are typically renewal-led, with short comparison-led buying for personal lines and longer advice-led work where cover is bespoke or claims history is awkward. Routes to market tend to be direct, referral-led or partner-influenced, with tendering used mainly where larger commercial clients want documented market testing.
What they buy
Most Sheffield insurance firms tend to spend on tools and services that reduce manual policy work, evidence compliance and keep renewal conversations moving. Relevant categories include CRM, policy administration, document management, e-signature, call recording, secure email, claims workflow, accounting, client-money reconciliation, marketing automation and cyber security. Smaller teams may also buy outsourced bookkeeping, compliance support, HR, payroll, recruitment and legal advice, especially where authorisation, appointed-representative arrangements or acquisition activity create extra checks. Infrastructure needs are usually practical rather than exotic: reliable telephony, cloud storage, backup, endpoint protection and reporting that can support audit trails without adding another layer of admin.
Why and how to sell to them
Pressure usually shows up around renewals, complaints, insurer appetite shifts, acquisition discussions and changes in authorisation status. Insurance buyers tend to evaluate vendors when admin starts to slow quote turnaround, when compliance evidence becomes difficult to assemble, or when a small team is trying to service a larger book without adding staff. Outbound works better when it is anchored in a specific operational risk: missed renewal dates, duplicated data entry, weak management information, slow claims updates or poor visibility of client-money movements. Generic efficiency claims are less persuasive than a clear route to fewer errors, cleaner files and faster customer contact.
How this list is built
Data sources
This list is built from UK Companies House filings, XBRL accounts data, and semantic analysis of each company's public website. Revenue and headcount figures come from the most recent filed accounts; where the company has not filed, values are estimated using a model trained on filed history and peer benchmarks and are labelled as estimates.
Classification
Rather than relying solely on SIC codes, Firmbase classifies each company semantically: the company's website is crawled, an AI model reads what the company actually sells, and the company is placed into the relevant industry and subsectors. SIC codes are used as one signal but not the only one. This means a company that registered under a generic SIC code but pivoted into (for example) fintech is correctly identified as fintech, not as its original SIC category.
Freshness
The underlying company data is refreshed from Companies House continuously; filings appear in the list within days of submission. The curated list ordering is regenerated when the underlying data moves meaningfully (company count changes by more than 5%, a new company enters the top-ranked segment, or the filed-revenue numbers for the top firms change). You can see the last-updated timestamp near the top of the page.
Also in Sheffield
Related directories
Frequently asked questions
How many insurance companies are there in Sheffield?
What counts as a insurance company in this list?
Which are the largest insurance companies in Sheffield?
What do insurance companies in Sheffield actually do?
How does Sheffield insurance compare internationally?
How is this list built and how fresh is the data?
How big are the typical insurance companies in Sheffield?
Are these mostly new or established insurance companies?
What SIC codes does this use?
What buying signals should I look for?
Push these 117 companies into your pipeline.
Find the right decision-makers, see verified company data, and export your list in seconds.